by
H. Clay Gorton
The
Starduster Magazine, Vol. 29, No. 4, Oct. 1999
To
maintain the center of gravity of an airplane within acceptable limits is
essential to flight. About five years ago a light plane landed at the Skypark
Bountiful airport. The plane had been purchased new and this was its first
flight. The pilot and two passengers took off from Skypark on a warm afternoon
with a full load of fuel and a packed baggage compartment. No checks were made
of gross weight or density altitude. This omission cost the lives of three
people. After taking off, the plane could not maintain altitude, plunged to the
earth and crashed and burned. Whether the plane was nose heavy or over grossed
is not known.
A
friend of mine who worked as a radio operator for Panagra on flights to South
America before the Second World War told of another serious accident related to
weight and balance. A cargo DC-3 had been loaded at the Mendoza, Argentina
airport, but the loadmaster had failed to secure the cargo. When the plane took
off the cargo shifted to the rear causing the plane to nose up. The pilot
corrected by pushing the yoke forward. When the plane began to nose down the
load shifted to the front of the cargo bay, pushing the center of gravity ahead
of the forward limit of the airplane, making it impossible to recover from the
dive. The plane was destroyed and all five occupants were killed.
Center of Gravity
Conventional
airplanes are considered to be in balance left to right, so the c.g. would be
somewhere along a centerline from front to rear. The acceptable limits of the
center of gravity for a Starduster Too are from 18 to 27 inches behind the
firewall.
Moment Arm
Datum
The
datum is an arbitrary line from which the distances to the various points of
interest in weight and balance are measured. The vertical datum is usually taken
as the firewall, since the manufacture’s specs for weight and balance are
always given in distances from the firewall. However, in practice, distances are
usually measured from the front point of the spinner, as it is easier to suspend
a plumb bob from that point to the floor, where the measurements are made.
The
horizontal datum is conveniently measured along on the top aileron. To do weight
and balance the airplane must be in a true horizontal position. This is achieved
with a spirit level placed on the top horizontal aileron.
Weight and Balance Equation
To
perform the weight and balance measurements, the weight of the aircraft under
each wheel must be determined, and the distances from center of the point of
contact of the wheels with the floor to the datum line must be measured. The
procedure to find the center of gravity (c.g.) of the aircraft is a simple one.
It comprises dividing the sum of the moments (distance from the datum to the
point at which the weight is measured) by the sum of the weights.
The
formula is written as follows:
| c. g. = | DL x WL + DR x WR + DT x WT |
| WL + WR + WT |
where
DL is the distance
from the datum to the center point of the left wheel,
DR
is the distance from the datum to the center point of the right wheel (these two
distances should be equal),
DT
is the distance from the datum to the center point of the tail wheel, and
WL,
WR, and WT are the weights measured under the left,
right and tail wheels, respectively.
Calculating Weight and Balance
Set-up: For a new aircraft the wt.
& bal. measurement must be made with the aircraft completely empty—no oil
and no fuel. (The FAA seems to prefer it that way.) However, if the aircraft is
not new, it is more convenient to make the measurements with the oil already
added, since the aircraft is never intentionally flown without oil.
The
wt. & bal. calculations must be made with the aircraft in a horizontal
position. First, scales must be placed under each of the three points of contact
of the airplane with the ground. Next the aircraft must be brought to a
horizontal position by raising the tail wheel until the top longeron is
horizontal, measured by a spirit level.
Measuring the moment arm: Since the manufacturer's
specs use the firewall as the datum, so shall we. The distance from the datum to
the center of the point of impact of the front wheels with scales must be
measured. It will be assumed that the two landing gear are properly aligned.
Drop a plumb bob from the firewall to the floor. Mark a line through the point
on the floor parallel to the alignment of the two wheels, so that the distance
from the line to each wheel is the same. This distance will be the moment arm
for the weights, WL and WR.
The
maximum forward c.g. limit is determined with the aircraft under the lightest
load. (The center point of all the weights to be added except for the oil are
located more than 18 inches behind the firewall, and so would increase the tail
heaviness of the airplane.) So the max. forward c.g. limited would be calculated
with no fuel, no baggage and one light pilot—dead stick landing! The
calculation of the max. forward c.g. limit is made using Table 2.
The
max. aft. c.g. limit is determined with a fully loaded airplane. Two methods may
be used to determine the c.g. of a loaded airplane. In the first method the
moment arm to the center of gravity of each component must be measured. This is
not always practical. For instance, where is the center of gravity of the oil in
the engine, or where is the center of gravity of the pilot seated in the
cockpit?
Tables 4, 5 and 6 are added as examples of the calculations for the three c.g.’s discussed above. It must be noted that the actual weights and distances will be unique to each aircraft measured.
Table 1. Empty Weight c.g. Calculations
| WEIGHING POINT | WEIGHT (-Tare), W, lbs | MOMENT ARM, D, in. | MOMENT, D x W, in. lbs. |
| Right Main (R) | |||
| Left Main (L) | |||
| Tail Wheel (T) | |||
| Total |
Table
2. Max. Forward c.g. Calculations
| WEIGHING POINT | WEIGHT (-tare), lbs. | MOMENT ARM, in. | MOMENT, in. lbs. |
| Right Main (1) | |||
| Left Main (2) | |||
| Tail Wheel (3) | |||
| Pilot | |||
| Oil | |||
| Total |
Table
3. Max. Aft c.g. Calculations
| WEIGHING POINT | WEIGHT (-tare), lbs. | MOMENT ARM, in. | MOMENT, in. lbs. |
| Right Main (1) | |||
| Left Main (2) | |||
| Tail Wheel (3) | |||
| Pilot | |||
| Copilot | |||
| Fuel, Main | |||
| Fuel, Wing | |||
| Baggage | |||
| Total |
Examples
Empty Weight c.g. Calculations
| WEIGHING POINT | WEIGHT (-Tare), W, lbs | MOMENT ARM, D, in. | MOMENT, D x W, in. lbs. |
| Right Main (R) | 610.0 | 7.5 | 4575.0 |
| Left Main (L) | 600.0 | 7.5 | 4500.0 |
| Tail Wheel (T) | 85.0 | 169.5 | 14407.5 |
| Total | 1295.0 | 23482.5 |
c.g. (empty) = 610x7.5 + 600x7.5 + 85x169.5 = 23482.5 = 18.13 in. behind firewall
Note that the specified forward limit is 18 inches behind the firewall. The empty airplane is within spec.
Max.
Forward c.g. Calculations
| WEIGHING POINT | WEIGHT (-tare), lbs. | MOMENT ARM, in. | MOMENT, in. lbs. |
| Right Main (1) | 610.0 | 7.5 | 4575.0 |
| Left Main (2) | 600.0 | 7.5 | 4500.0 |
| Tail Wheel (3) | 85.0 | 169.5 | 14407.5 |
| Pilot | 175.0 | 70.0 | 12250.0 |
| Oil | |||
| Total | 1470.0 | 35732.5 |
c.g. (max forward) = 610x7.5 + 600x7.5 + 85x169.5 + 175x70 = 35732.5 = 24.3 in. behind firewall
Max.
Aft c.g. Calculations
| WEIGHING POINT | WEIGHT (-tare), lbs. | MOMENT ARM, in. | MOMENT, in. lbs. |
| Right Main (1) | 610.0 | 7.5 | 4575.0 |
| Left Main (2) | 600.0 | 7.5 | 4500.0 |
| Tail Wheel (3) | 85.0 | 169.5 | 14407.5 |
| Pilot | 200.0 | 70.0 | 14000.0 |
| Copilot | 175.0 | 40.0 | 7000.0 |
| Fuel, Main | 150.0 | 9.0 | 1350.0 |
| Fuel, Wing | 102.0 | 19.0 | 1938.0 |
| Baggage | 20.0 | 96.0 | 1920.0 |
| Total | 1942.0 | 49690.0 |
c.g. (max aft) = 49690.0 = 25.58 in. behind firewall
In the above example, the maximum forward and aft c.g.'s of 18.13 in. and 25.58 in. are within the limits of 18 to 27 in. behind the firewall.